बहिरन्तश्च भूतानामचरं चरमेव च | सूक्ष्मत्वात्तदविज्ञेयं दूरस्थं चान्तिके च तत् ||१३-१६||
bahirantaśca bhūtānāmacaraṃ carameva ca .
sūkṣmatvāttadavijñeyaṃ dūrasthaṃ cāntike ca tat ||13-16||
Without and within (all) beings the unmoving and also the moving; because of Its subtlety, unknowable; and near and far away is That.
In simple words
Krishna describes something beyond ordinary understanding: "It exists outside and inside all beings. It does not move, yet it moves. It is so subtle that it cannot be grasped. It is both infinitely far and incredibly close."
बहिःwithoutअन्तःwithinचandभूतानाम्of (all) beingsअचरम्the unmovingचरम्the movingएवalsoचandसूक्ष्मत्वात्because of Its subtletyतत्Thatअविज्ञेयम्unknowableदूरस्थम्is farचandअन्तिकेnear
Contemporary scholarly and practical interpretations for modern seekers.
Swami Sivananda
13.16 बहिः without? अन्तः within? च and? भूतानाम् of (all) beings? अचरम् the unmoving? चरम् the moving? एव also? च and? सूक्ष्मत्वात् because of Its subtlety? तत् That? अविज्ञेयम् unknowable? दूरस्थम् is far? च and? अन्तिके near? च and? तत् That.Commentary Brahman is subtle like the ether. It is incomprehensible to the unillumined on account of Its extreme subtlety. It is unknowable to the man who is not endowed with the four means of salvation.Brahman is known or realised by the wise. It is realised by the first class aspirant who is eipped with these means. It is near to the wise man or the illumined because It is his very Self. It is very far to the ignorant man who is drowned in worldliness or sensual pleasures. It is not attainable by the ignorant or unenlightened even in millions of years.Near and far away This expression is found in the Isavasya Upanishad (5) and the Mundaka Upanishad (3.17).
Swami Chinmayananda
This interpretation draws on a specific tradition and may not represent the view of any single school. For authoritative guidance within a specific tradition, seek a qualified teacher.
# BG 13.16 — The Omnipresence of the Supreme Self
The omnipresence of the Supreme Self is here indicated in the incomparable style of the Upanishads. That Supreme Self pervades all beings both within and without — the conscious principle expressed through all individual conditions is all-pervading. By "within and without" is meant that where bodies and other limiting conditions exist, the Supreme Self is distinctly manifest and present; yet even where no such condition exists, it remains established in its pure being alone. Just as radio waves exist clearly where a radio receiver is present, yet their absence cannot be affirmed where no receiver exists — so too does the Supreme Self pervade all space.
The Supreme Self is both the moving and the unmoved. That which moves about by its own will is a moving being, while that which is motionless belongs to the stationary category. Yet this statement also means that the Self, though unmoved in its essential nature, appears to move. This is because the Self, being all-pervading, is unchanging in its own form; yet when associated with moving conditions, it appears to move — like a person sitting still in a moving vehicle who traverses miles of distance without leaving his seat. Thus the essential substance of our being is one, eternal, and complete, pervading everywhere within and without. Without it, no action is possible; therefore it exists in all actions. It is established everywhere in its true nature.
Why then cannot we perceive it through the senses, or experience it through mind and intellect? The Lord declares: because it is supremely subtle and therefore unknowable to ordinary perception. Objects with qualities are gross. The more qualities an object possesses, the grosser it becomes and the more it can be grasped by multiple senses. Earth, for instance, is known through all five senses, while air is known only through hearing and touch. Thus earth is the grossest element, and space, possessing only the quality of sound, is the subtlest.
The cause is always subtler than the effect. Space, being a created thing, must have a cause. That eternal substratum, Brahman, is the cause of space itself and of the five great elements. Naturally, Brahman, being subtler even than space, cannot be known as an object through our available means of knowledge — it is unknowable.
The Supreme Self is both distant and near. A finite, limited object can be said to exist in a particular place — here or there — and its distance from the observer can be measured and it can be called distant or near. But that which is all-pervading exists here and there simultaneously, and is therefore both distant and near. These terms can also be understood thus: the Supreme Self is distant, being free from all names and forms and their limiting conditions; yet that same Supreme Self is near, dwelling within all names and forms. Sri Shankara writes in his commentary that this Self appears extremely distant to the ignorant, while the wise experience it as supremely near, as their own innermost Self.
In essence, this verse, adorned with the beauty of paradoxical language, awakens those readers who are satisfied with intellectual knowledge alone. It inspires them to directly experience through reflection and meditation the all-pervading and transcendent nature of the Supreme Self.
Regarding this very subject, the Lord continues to speak.